Bayou Renaiscance Man has an excellent series of four articles discussing the crisis erupting globally within the Catholic church over sexual abuse of children by clergy. 

He discusses the basic structure of the church, the process of becoming a priest and how it might add to the problem, priestly celibacy, and the churches response to the crisis.

Go read his articles, then come back for my commentary.

First, some background:

As some of you know, I consider myself a lapsed Catholic.  I was born into a Lutheran family, and celebrated my faith in that mostly Catholic environment until my parents divorced when I was 12.  My mother then went on a tour of all the local denominations, and took us along for the ride.  When she met my step-father, she, along with all of us kids, entered the Catholic church.  The stability and serene environment of the Church after several years of holy-rollers and snake handlers brought a lot of comfort to me, and I stayed in the faith even after I was divorced and could no longer take part in all of the sacraments.

When Irish Woman and I met and wanted to marry, a problem was found.  You see, it was hard to get an annulment of my previous marriage when all of the witnesses were scattered to the four winds by military life.  After a year and a half of working with the local diocese, we decided that it would be best if we went outside the Church for our marriage and life afterwards.  It wasn’t just the issue of the annulment, but let’s just say it was the final straw.  The way that the church in Louisville specifically and the U.S. generally was dealing with the sex abuse scandal, along with other issues, led us to look elsewhere.

Luckily, we found a small Episcopalean congregation that accepted us, flaws and all, as full members of their family immediately after we entered their chapel.  Other than the fact that the Father is really a father, the sacraments and beliefs are very close to what we were both used to.  And when we go for counseling to our priest, he can empathize with us about our problems as a couple and as parents. 

Here is my take on the abuse scandal within the church, and they mostly parallel what BRM has to say:

1. Clergy who have harmed their parishioners, child or adult, male or female, in such a reprehensible manner need to be defrocked.  They can be forgiven for their acts if they express true contrition and sin no more, but they should never be trusted in a capacity that would allow them to have authority in the Church.  If a priest breaks his vow of celibacy with a willing adult woman, he can be defrocked.  Why should the penalty for forced sex with a minor be less?
2. The Church should be open and transparent on how it deals with these fallen men and women.  Nothing cleans out a problem like sunlight.  The secrecy and stonewalling the Church has practiced so far have done more to harm Her than anything wayward priests have done.  It’s not the crime, it’s the cover-up that causes the most harm.  Bishops and other church officials who have facilitated this abuse by trying to either ignore the problem or shuffle problem priests around after “treatment” should be removed from their vocation.
3. Each and every bishop in the church should meet with the victims of sexual abuse in his diocese and sincerely and vociferously apologize.  He should offer any and all resources of the Church that can be used for treatment of the harm done to these people.  He should also offer any and all measures available to atone to them for the heinous crime that a representative of the Church inflicted on them.

I have no expertise in how a seminarian should be indoctrinated on his responsibilities to his flock, or how those who are at great risk of doing such horrible things should be filtered out of the seminaries.  I also will not comment on the applicability of celibacy in our modern world.  All I can say is that celibacy is one of the punches on the ordination ticket.  If someone does not feel that they can faithfully remain celibate as a condition of their ordination, then they should not be ordained.  Whether or not we should allow Catholic priests to marry and all that that entails, I will leave up to those who know more about it than I.

Those who harm children are the lowest of the low.  Those who enable them are just as bad.  The leadership of the Church needs to be honest with itself, with its parishioners, and with the world at large on this problem.  Only when the light of day is shone on those who harm those entrusted to their care, those who have been harmed have been healed, and a way is found to prevent such things from happening will the Church regain its reputation in the world.

I’m pleasantly surprised that President Obama is going in person to Poland for the funeral of the Polish president.  I half expected him to send Cussin’ Joe Biden.  Guess Joe hasn’t been let out of the pit in the basement of the White House yet.

Obama has seemingly gone out of his way to insult our friends and allies, including Poland.  The Poles I met when I was in the military were very pro-Western, and especially pro-American.  Poland has worked hard in the years since they got the Soviet troops out of their country to become a productive member of NATO, including offering to house our troops and missile emplacements.  On a couple of occasions, President Obama has kicked Poland in the teeth in attempts to curry favor from Russia.

Now, that country has been pretty much decapitated.  The Poles are still trying to get their legs underneath themselves, and any moral assistance we can give them will probably help.  

Obama going to Poland will go a long way to heal wounds that his treatment of our European allies has caused.  He just needs to remember this:  the trip is not about him.  He is going to pay his respects to the leader of a friendly nation, and by so doing show how much that nation means to our country.  He is not there for sound-bites or photo-ops.  Classiest thing he can do while he’s there is to tell the press that he’s not going to answer any questions, and that he’s only there to share in the grief of the Polish people.  I hope that he shows at least some class here.

I was going to say something about the dumbass who is refusing to deploy to Afghanistan because he believes that President Obama can’t be president due to the supposed location of his birth.

But Uncle Jimbo over at Blackfive beat me to the punch and did it in a very good way. 

My favorite line:

We’ve been around this block enough times, but to clarify once again- Officers in the military do not get to question the credentials of those lawfully appointed over them.

 Here’s my take on it:  What this jerk pulled not only hurts himself, but makes life harder on the soldiers he has trained and worked with.  Their team has lost a member, which means that whatever expertise he has is gone, and must be made up by someone else.  Deployment is hard enough.  It’s even harder when you have to do your job and someone else’s too.

I hope they throw the book at this guy and he lives a long time to regret it.

Two years ago this evening, a small, wonderful, strong package of stubbornness entered my life.

Since then, I’ve been fortunate to re-live all of the parts of raising a small child that I love, and I’m experienced enough to side step those parts I dislike.

He started this day as he started his first day, crying and in a bad mood.  He’s a chip off the old block.

Over at Monster Hunter Nation, Larry Correia has posted the first 7 chapters of his upcoming novel, “The Grimnoir Chronicles:  Hard Magic”.  Larry is fast becoming one of my favorite story tellers. 

The story will appeal to you if you enjoy the noir detective novels from the 40’s and 50’s.  Or if you like science fiction/fantasy. Or heck if you just enjoy a good yarn.

Go, enjoy.  Leave Mr. Correia a comment or two so he knows we appreciate him giving us a taste. Of course, he’ll make money on the comeback, like any dealer.

After I left the machine gun shoot, I picked up Little Bear from his grandmother’s house.  We got home, cleaned up, and took possession of an additional young lady for the night.  One of Girlie Bear’s school friends came over for a sleep over.  I piled the older kids into the car, and took them to see How to Train Your Dragon.  If you haven’t seen it, it’s a great movie.  Definitely going to be a buyer when it comes out around Christmas.

Dinner was grilled out hamburgers and hotdogs, followed by toasted marshmallows over the grill.  Nothing like filling young people up with sugar to make an evening exciting.

Overheard during the marshmallow roasting:

DaddyBear – I’m going in to grab a jacket.  You guys be good for a few minutes.
Little Bear – Don’t worry, I’ll watch them.
Girlie Bear – Whatever
Little Bear – I’m older!  You respect your elders!
Girlie Bear and friend, in harmony – Whatever!

Currently, the kids are enjoying some video games in lieu of another movie.  Girlie Bear’s friend is kicking both of the others’ butts at Wii Sports Resort. 

Now that I’ve had two eleven year old girls in close proximity to both each other and me for a few hours, I know why I’m glad Girlie Bear wasn’t a twin.  They’ve all been very well behaved, but they’ve been twittering like birds since 3 this afternoon.  Oh well, better chattering than sullen silence.

I’m looking forward to going to bed in a few hours.  Hopefully the girls will get at least a few minutes of sleep tonight.

Took a morning jaunt down to Knob Creek for their spring machine gun shoot, and a good time was had by all.  It’s funny when you realize that  a .50 caliber sniper rifle doesn’t sound so loud when it’s competing with machine guns and cannons.  I personally didn’t pay to shoot automatic weapons, but it’s almost as much fun to watch other people do it.

The accompanying gun show was also excellent.  If you were looking for something and couldn’t find it, you weren’t looking hard enough.  Only thing I was looking for was a .22 conversion kit for my1911, and they had them.  I can get a better price online, so I passed.  I did buy 100 rounds of .38 at a really good price.  The ammunition situation appears to be loosening up, at least for common calibers.  Lots of 7.62×39, 7.62×54, .308, and .223 to be found.  The only one I didn’t see was .380, and it may have sold out yesterday.

Props to the crew at Knob Creek, who are as always on the ball.  I don’t expect to ever meet a nicer, more professional group of people.  I’m definitely going to go back in the future.

Here are a few pics of the festivities

Dude, if you hide your stash in your kid’s school bag, make sure you get it before he leaves for the bus.

If you forget, then be cool.  Calling the school to see if you can come get something you put in his bag tends to get them interested in exactly what it is.

Have fun trying to figure out prison etiquette over 4 ounces of weed in an Elmo bag.

So the president doesn’t like nuclear weapons.  No-one does.    I grew up next to missile and bomber bases.  B-52’s used to use my elementary school as a notional target because the land around it resembled their actual wartime targets.  We had at least two ‘civil defense’ drills every year, which is code for ‘nuclear war’ drills.  We knew that if the balloon ever went up for real, our city was a first strike target, and there wasn’t much sense in planning for the aftermath.

Nukes are weapons of mass destruction.  They kill and destroy without regard to age, sex, or military designation.  They are really only good against large targets such as cities, unless we choose to use a small arsenal of penetrator warheads to hit underground bunkers, and even then the lingering after effects of radiation will hurt the surrounding population for generations.

However, the understood threat that our large nuclear arsenal would be unleashed against any power, nation state or otherwise, that used any weapon of mass destruction against us, has been around longer than I have been alive.  A biological weapon is a chemical weapon is a nuclear weapon.  A mass nerve gas attack against Baltimore would be treated as if someone had fired an ICBM into the harbor.

Also, the knowledge that we were willing, in very limited circumstances, to use nuclear weapons to defend western Europe and other allies kept the Soviet bear at bay long enough that he crumbled from the inside.  Without this umbrella of menace that we stretched across the Fulda Gap, it is hard to imagine the Soviets not taking advantage of their local superiority to take over Europe. 

So even though the use of nuclear weapons is horrific and probably immoral, their threatened use if we or our allies are attacked has been and is a strong deterrent against the portions of the world that wish us ill.

So now the president has made a public pledge to not use nuclear weapons against non-nuclear nations.  Instead a threat of massive conventional retaliation takes the place of a nuclear deterrent.  So if a country decides to gas one of our cities, or releases a biological agent into our food system, we promise to bomb them with HE.  Sure, we’ll do a lot of damage, but if someone is planning an attack like that, they will make sure the parts of their country they need protected from a conventional attack are either buried or dispersed.  Nuclear weapons can, through the use of penetrators or just their large explosive power make burying of assets useless.  And their large blast radii can make dispersal of a countries military into the hinterlands less effective. 

In addition, the president has pledged to stop development and improvement of our aging stockpile.  So even if he decides to use these weapons, there is no guarantee that they will work.  Imagine what will happen if a multi-megaton warhead fails to go off over its target.  Think the target will be saturated with second strikes to not only destroy the target but keep an example of American nuclear technology from being picked apart and studied?  Think the warhead would be paraded through the streets of a capital as a symbol of American impotence?  You have to do maintenance and testing of any system that you plan on ever using.  By stopping testing and development of our deterrent, the president puts us in danger.

Also, I don’t believe the president.  In the heat of the moment, if our homeland has been attacked with a weapon of mass destruction and the president is watching some people die and others cry out for revenge on CNN, I think his emotions will override his pledge.  He will lash out out of fear and anger.  And his fear of political retaliation will drive him to make a politically expedient choice.  He will lay waste to another nation so that he can continue to be the “leader” of this nation.

So, the president has made a pledge that I feel makes us less secure in a world that is looking for openings to harm us.  His pledge will embolden those who want to attack the American homeland. And it means nothing when coming from an administration that will forget it in the name of political expediency when a poll of eligible voters shows they want blood to run in the streets of whatever country attacked us.

At least, according to my last personnel review:

H/T to Dr. Grumpy.