• Archives

  • Topics

  • Meta

  • The Boogeyman - Working Vacation
  • Coming Home
  • Quest To the North
  • Via Serica
  • Tales of the Minivandians
  • Join the NRA

    Join the NRA!

A Damn Shame

Last night, a  woman was allegedly horribly beaten and stabbed to death by her boyfriend.   The child the couple brought into this world was in their home at the time, and there were witnesses to the crime.  It appears that the alleged murderer and abuser has previous convictions for domestic abuse, as well as violating protective orders.  He was arrested a few days ago for abusing the victim in this case, but was released on his own recognizance on Wednesday, the day that the victim also allowed a temporary protective order to lapse.

Witnesses say that they saw the defendant beat and stab the victim in several locations in the house, and that they even tried to intervene to save her.  They claim that they backed off when he tried to cut them with the knife that he was using to carve up the mother of his child.

So what we have here is someone who has been convicted of domestic abuse on multiple occasions being arrested yet again for using his significant other as a speed bag, but being let out of his cage with nothing but a stern warning to be a good boy while he awaits trial.  We have a young mother who has nothing to defend herself except for the honor of the man who she accused of bouncing her off of furniture for fun and profit.  We have adult witnesses who were not able to get him off of her because all they had was their bare hands.

What we have here is the inevitable outcome of what happens to the weak when they are denied effective defensive tools and are confronted by the strong.

That is the insanity of the gun control laws in places like Massachusetts.  Would Ms. Martel still be alive if she had owned a gun?  I don’t know, but I do know she would have had a better chance at survival armed than she did when her boyfriend got out of jail and came over for one last sparring match.  But she was prohibited from walking out of that courthouse on Tuesday and walking into a gun store and purchasing the single most effective defensive tool known to man.  Heck, as I understand the laws in Massachusetts, she didn’t even have the option of calling someone she knows who already owns a gun and getting a loaner.  Her neighbors, who tried to help her, were also hamstrung because all they had at their disposal when they tried to pull a large, muscular, allegedly murderously enraged man off of her were their bare hands.

Instead, they were all left to the mercy of someone with a history of using women as kinetic stress reducers.

Ladies, I’m not going to promise that a gun will magically save you from an attacker, be he some psycho who randomly picked you out of the herd or be he the father of your children.  It’s a tool, not a talisman, and the mere presence of a gun does not guarantee good outcomes, just as its presence does not cause bad outcomes.  But like any tool, if used properly and judiciously, it can mean the difference between success and failure in a situation where failure means death of the innocent or worse.

Ladies, and especially mothers, please take a moment to think about how much you love your life and the lives of your children.  No-one wants to hurt or kill someone else when they cherish life, but in instances like this, you have to weigh the life of your attacker against the value of your life and what you add to the lives of your children.  Please, do not let all of that be protected only by a piece of paper and the honor of those who have no sense of honor.  Protect yourselves, with whatever means you can get.

You are too precious to have that happen to you, even if I never met you.

 

 

UPDATE – Credit where credit is due.  I realized after I wrote  this that I borrowed heavily from Kathy Jackson in “The Cornered Cat:  A Woman’s Guide to Concealed Carry” when I was writing the last paragraph or two.  It was unintentional, but I definitely want Kathy to get credit for the sentiment I was trying to get across.

Previous Post
Next Post

5 Comments

  1. AndyN's avatar

    AndyN

     /  August 16, 2013

    At the risk of sounding like I’m blaming the victim, two things occur to me.

    First, it’s hard to help people who don’t want to help themselves. According to the article, the victim has been the murderer’s girlfriend since the year he plead guilty to abusing his last girlfriend. Although she got a temporary restraining order Tuesday night, part of the reason that the murderer was released from custody was because she didn’t return when court was open Wednesday to have the restraining order made non-temporary.

    Second, maybe the problem isn’t that Massholes aren’t allowed to own guns, maybe the problem is that they don’t really want the responsibility of defending themselves. Seeing that guy’s picture, I’m positive that I wouldn’t have been able to stop him from doing whatever he wanted with my bare hands. That said, if I was one of the neighbors who tried to intervene, I’d bet everything I own that I could have found an equalizer in her kitchen, and if I hadn’t been able to stop him he’d at least have known that he’d been in a fight.

    Like

    • daddybear71's avatar

      AndyN, I agree there were definitely things that the victim could have done differently that would have either changed the outcome or given her more of a fighting chance. But I want to point out that no matter how ‘wrong’, in retrospect, her choices were, she in no way invited her murder. Just as a woman be able to wear whatever she wants without worrying about rape or a man should be able to carry whatever amount of money he wants to without fear of robber, she should have been able to live her life without fear of someone murdering her, if indeed that is what happened here. Yes, there are things she could have done differently, but the only person responsible for her death, if he is found guilty of causing it, is the defendant.

      As for whether the witnesses could have done more than try to pull him off with what they had available, all I can say is that I wasn’t there. It’s quite possible that there wasn’t time to run to another room for a weapon or to think about an alternative to bare hands from what was available at hand. I do hope that if I were in the same situation, I would have the presence of mind to grab whatever was handy to use as a bludgeon or blade.

      Like

  2. Old NFO's avatar

    Well said, and one more truly sad death… NEEDLESSLY!

    Like

  1. Gun control, baseball and death | AKs & Cupcakes